Nexus 7 First Impressions

I picked up a Nexus 7 this weekend.

It is a nice device, at a good price.

My initial impressions are that Google has caught up and is now in the lead in some areas compared to Apple.

Some notable advantages:

– Multiple users per device are supported

– Gmail is a better email client then the iOS email client

– Google Wallet is as easy to use as iTunes for purchases and increasingly more convenient since iTunes purchasing has fragmented the experience relative to some content providers not being integrated, e.g. Kindle eBooks.

– Google Play store is much easier to browse, find and share things then iTunes (they have made huge improvements over the last year)

– Widgets

– Active wallpaper

– Folders that can be placed in the bottom navigation panel

– Google Maps is years ahead of the iOS Maps in terms of features, integration, accuracy, POI — by itself that feature makes Google the leader over Apple

– Google Search integration

– Google Now is very innovative and an advantage that Apple will be hard-pressed to compete with

– Notifications center is better then Apple – much easier to work with, better integration with apps

Uncertainties:

– Siri on Apple is currently DOA

– NFC on Google is currently DOA

Disadvantages relative to Apple:

– They took a step backward on the Nexus 7 by eliminating support for an SD card memory expansion

– No camera on back, only a screen-side camera

– Device security relative to malware

– Device quality is low, for instance the device has uneven frame height around the edges where the glass and the metal meet; plastic backing has a cheap and slippery feel to it

– Android apps are a crap-shoot on whether they work well or not in the screen size and resolution, some apps failed to download or install

– Android apps are still inconsistent in user experience in general

– Platform fragmentation

– Maximum screen brightness is lower then Apple devices – the device is difficult to view on bright light

– No Passbook feature

—-

Dec 25 update after a few weeks with the Nexus 7

The Nexus 7 is fragile –  I accidentally dropped it onto a carpeted floor and it stopped working.  I pried off the back and found out that the battery connector to the circuit board had come partially off.  Unlike other connectors it had not been taped down or otherwise secured.  After reseating it the Nexus worked again.

Battery life is very mediocre – watching one 90 min movie pretty much kills the battery.

Maximum audio volume for the built-in speakers is very low compared to iPad devices.

I am more convinced then ever that Google has taken the lead.  I have not used my iPad since picking up the Nexus.

Advertisements

iPhone, Samsung, Nokia, HTC – likes/dislikes

I’ve been playing with iPhone, Samsung, HTC and Nokia phones and was reflecting on what  I like/dislike about each:

Samsung Galaxy SIII:

+ great screen (bright, crisp)

+ very responsive

+ comfortable to hold (smooth edges, light)

+ great photo quality

+ microSD card support

+ replaceable battery

+ microUSB charger / sync cable

+ google goggles

– S-Voice

– screen is too wide to easily work with the apps – needs both hands to use the device

– Android OS and apps are not consistent in interaction behaviours

HTC One V:

+ great screen (bright, crisp)

+ can manipulate apps using one hand

+ microSD card support

+ microUSB charger / sync cable

– no replaceable battery

– poor photo quality

– laggy response on launching apps

– Android OS and apps are not consistent in interaction behaviours

– Android OS update to latest version not available

Nokia 900:

+ great screen (bright, crisp)

+ microUSB charger / sync cable

– no replaceable battery

– no microSD card support

– poor photo quality

– uncomfortable to hold (heavy, blocky edges)

– button placement on right side of device not only makes device uncomfortable to hold, but also makes for unintended button pushes

– screen is too wide to easily work with the apps – need both hands to use the device

– WP7 Metro interface is terrible (inconsistent, non-intuitive, clunky, spurious visual effects) – it felt antiquated rather then new

– Not upgradable to WP8

iPhone 4S:

+ great screen (bright, crisp)

+ very responsive

+ great photo quality (with HDR enabled)

+ OS and apps are consistent in interaction behaviours

+ can manipulate apps using one hand

+ iOS updates available to latest version

– SIRI

– no microSD card support

– no replaceable battery

– no microUSB charger / sync cable  (proprietary & expensive connector)

 

I learned a new word today “SKEUOMORPHISM”

I came across this article about the termination of two senior Apple staff – Reports Claim Forstall And Browett Were Asked To Leave Apple Following Crucial Missteps.

The article noted that one executive was responsible for the “SKEUOMORPHISM” that pervades iOS and is considered a source of tension within the company.   I didn’t even know what the word meant, let alone that it was an issue with iOS.

After digging around a bit, it turns out that “SKEUOMORPHISM” is a catch-all term for when objects retain ornamental elements of past, derivative iterations–elements that are no longer necessary to the current objects’ functions.  Examples in iOS include: calendars with faux leather-stitching, bookshelves with wood veneers, fake glass and paper and brushed chrome.

For my part I like those ornamental elements… it is part of what sets Apple apart.

Apparently the main people that find this a problem are designers.

NFC = “Not for Commerce”

“EBay Inc Chief Executive John Donahoe often quotes a merchant saying NFC stands for “Not For Commerce” – and dismisses the prospects of Near Field Communication technology used to turn cellphones into mobile wallets.”

Ref: Reuters

NFC is technology that is a solution searching for a problem…  it adds cost to mobile phone designs and will never be ubiquitous for mobile phone users (or for businesses).

This article provides a good overview – http://www.telecoms.com/52005/mobile-industry-still-placing-far-too-much-emphasis-on-nfc/