Unemployment in Canada will be 10% or higher in 2009..

The following table is based on historical data from Statistics Canada, it shows the tight coupling of US and Canada unemployment rates, with the Canadian rates generally lagging the US.  The Canadian unemployment rates have been historically higher then the US by anywhere up to 4%:

unemployment
Click to Expand

The current unemployment numbers for the US and Canada are as follows:

  • United States Department of Labor states the current unemployment rate as 8.1% as of February 2009.   States with double digit employment in January 2009 were reported as: California 10.1%, Michigan 11.16%, Rhode Island 10.3%, South Carolina 10.4%.
us-unemployment
US Department of Labor, Feb 6, 2009 - Unemployment Rate
  • Statistics Canada states the current unemployment rate as 7.7% as of February 2009, with Ontario at 8.7% unemployment

unemploymentrate
Statistics Canada, March 13 2009 - Unemployment Rate

The  historically tight coupling of the US and Canada unemployment rates mean that US forecasts can be reasonably used as a proxy for future Canadian unemployment rates.   Some sources and their forecasts for the 2009 US unemployment rate follow:

screenshot_64
Click to Expand

Bank of Montreal is forecasting a US unemployment rate of 9.3% in 4Q09.

Royal Bank of Canada is forecasting a US unemployment rate of 8.8% in 4Q09.

Based on the current forecast US unemployment rates and past trends, I expect the Canadian unemployment rate to rise to over 10% and potentially over 14% nationally by 4Q09. (NOTE: Toronto Dominion bank’s March forecasts expect Canadian unemployment to reach 9.9% by 4Q09.)

The coupling of the Canada and US unemployment rates  is interesting in many ways.  In particular, there are academic papers that examine the question of Canadian government policy –  specifically, can Canadian policy have any significant impact on Canadian unemployment numbers due to the tight coupling of our economy to that of the US?

My sense is our government, in general, has little hope of stopping Canadian unemployment rates from following that of the US.   I believe that from a practical perspective, all our government can reasonably do is moderate the impact of the unemployment growth with special social and employment programs; and sustain our economy and workforce until the US economy recovers by driving infrastructure and  entrepreneurial economic development programs.

In order to break the cycle, the Canadian government should be actively working to diversify our economy by  aggressively fostering new small business development and developing export relationships and associated selling channels with other countries outside of the US.

Some interesting articles and papers on the US and Canada unemployment numbers include the following:

A factor that can have a big impact on the rate of unemployment growth is what protectionist actions are taken by Canada, the US and others.  It is almost inevitable that if the recession continues to deepen — politicians will find protectionism as  one of the last tools in their basket of options to try.   Already the politicians are dancing around this topic – some articles on this topic are below:

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Unemployment in Canada will be 10% or higher in 2009..

  1. Pingback: Great Depression Unemployment versus 2009 and the Coming Storm? « Brian Hurley’s Blog

  2. Pingback: Canadian Unemployment in February Hits 7.7% « Brian Hurley’s Blog

  3. Pingback: Canadian Unemployment Rate Hits 8% in March « Brian Hurley’s Blog

  4. Matt Dell

    This is definitely true, layoffs like crazy in the software development sector. I graduated in April this year and still no job. The market is dry, and getting worse.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s