I’ve been playing with iPhone, Samsung, HTC and Nokia phones and was reflecting on what I like/dislike about each:
Samsung Galaxy SIII:
+ great screen (bright, crisp)
+ very responsive
+ comfortable to hold (smooth edges, light)
+ great photo quality
+ microSD card support
+ replaceable battery
+ microUSB charger / sync cable
+ google goggles
- S-Voice
- screen is too wide to easily work with the apps – needs both hands to use the device
- Android OS and apps are not consistent in interaction behaviours
HTC One V:
+ great screen (bright, crisp)
+ can manipulate apps using one hand
+ microSD card support
+ microUSB charger / sync cable
- no replaceable battery
- poor photo quality
- laggy response on launching apps
- Android OS and apps are not consistent in interaction behaviours
- Android OS update to latest version not available
Nokia 900:
+ great screen (bright, crisp)
+ microUSB charger / sync cable
- no replaceable battery
- no microSD card support
- poor photo quality
- uncomfortable to hold (heavy, blocky edges)
- button placement on right side of device not only makes device uncomfortable to hold, but also makes for unintended button pushes
- screen is too wide to easily work with the apps – need both hands to use the device
- WP7 Metro interface is terrible (inconsistent, non-intuitive, clunky, spurious visual effects) – it felt antiquated rather then new
- Not upgradable to WP8
iPhone 4S:
+ great screen (bright, crisp)
+ very responsive
+ great photo quality (with HDR enabled)
+ OS and apps are consistent in interaction behaviours
+ can manipulate apps using one hand
+ iOS updates available to latest version
- SIRI
- no microSD card support
- no replaceable battery
- no microUSB charger / sync cable (proprietary & expensive connector)